"Should I take a suitcase or a backpack?" It's one of the questions we're asked most before a trip, and I've asked it myself more times than I can count.
I've travelled with a suitcase and wished I'd brought a backpack, hauling it up narrow stairs and cursing my past self. I've also carried a backpack so heavy that I couldn't face picking it up again. So rather than telling you "it depends", this guide gives you the honest pros and cons, a quick comparison, and a straight answer for each type of trip.
The short answer
- Take a suitcase
for city breaks, UK weekends, ski trips and any trip where you stay in hotels and your luggage travels by coach or car. - Take a backpack or soft holdall
for sailing, small boats, jungle lodges and trips with lots of stairs, sand or cobbles. - Consider a wheeled backpack
if you want both: wheels for airports and smooth pavements, straps for everything else.
Where are you going?
Your destination matters more than anything else. Dragging a suitcase across a beach will make you want to throw it in the sea. Cobbled old towns, ferry ramps and hotels without lifts are just as unforgiving.
On the other hand, a city break with smooth pavements, lifts and taxis is exactly what wheels were made for. You'll arrive without a sweaty back or sore shoulders.
How will your luggage travel?
This is the question most people forget to ask. On many group tours, your bags go from airport to coach to hotel with very little carrying on your part, so a suitcase works perfectly.
The picture changes when your bags go on small boats, get passed hand to hand, or need to fit into a cabin. Rigid cases are hard to store and easy to damage, while soft bags squash into corners and survive being handled.
How long are you going for?
On longer trips, organisation becomes everything. Suitcases open flat, so it's easy to see and reach your clothes. With a backpack, unless it has a zip that opens all the way round, you'll find yourself digging for that one top at the bottom.
Whichever you choose, my biggest tip is packing cubes. Keep tops, bottoms, underwear and swimwear in separate cubes and you can unpack in minutes, find anything instantly and repack quickly when you move on. They're cheap and a genuine lifesaver.
How much are you taking?
An empty backpack is lighter than an empty suitcase, which leaves more of your airline allowance for actual belongings. But you can wheel far more weight than you can comfortably carry, and a suitcase fits more in, more neatly.
If your trip includes nice dinners and you want a dress or two that isn't creased and damp, a suitcase will make you happier. Backpacks have their own tricks, though: you can clip wet swimwear in a bag to the outside, or tie muddy shoes on by the laces.
Whatever you take, check your airline's size and weight limits before you pack, as they vary between airlines and fare types.
Durability vs protection
Backpacks are usually tougher. They're built for the outdoors, and there are no wheels or telescopic handles to snap. If your luggage will be thrown onto ferries, buses or boat roofs, a backpack or soft holdall is the safer bet.
Suitcases, especially hard-shell ones, protect what's inside far better. If you're carrying anything fragile, or souvenirs you don't want crushed, a hard case is worth it.
Our verdict for each type of trip
City breaks and UK weekends: suitcase
For trips like the Budapest Christmas Markets or our UK breaks, a small wheeled suitcase is ideal. Short transfers, hotels or cottages, and no long walks with your bags. For a weekend, cabin size is plenty.
Multi-stop tours: medium suitcase, packed light
On trips like Vietnam North to South or Japan Cherry Blossoms, you move every few days, but bags mostly travel by coach between hotels. A medium suitcase works well. The key is keeping it light enough to lift onto a coach or up a few steps yourself. If you can't lift it comfortably, you've packed too much.
Sailing and boat trips: soft holdall or backpack
On Croatia sailing or Galápagos trips, cabin storage is tight and rigid cases are hard to stow. A soft holdall or backpack that you can squash flat is much easier.
Jungle and wildlife trips: backpack or soft holdall
In Borneo or Costa Rica, expect small boats, muddy paths and lodges where wheels are useless. A backpack or rugged holdall is best. Pack a dry bag inside to keep things dry in humid weather and on boat transfers.
Winter and ski trips: suitcase
For Finland, Iceland or skiing in Morzine, bulky layers take up a lot of space, so a larger suitcase makes sense. Choose one with sturdy wheels, as small wheels struggle in snow, and wear your bulkiest boots and coat on the plane to save room.

What about the in-between options?
You don't have to choose one extreme. These hybrids solve a lot of problems:
- Wheeled backpack:
wheels for airports, straps for stairs and sand. Heavier than a normal backpack, but very flexible. - Wheeled holdall:
soft and squashable like a bag, with wheels at one end. Great for boats and coaches. - Suitcase plus daypack:
the most popular combination on our trips. The suitcase stays at the hotel or on the coach, and a small daypack carries your water, sun cream, camera and passport each day.
Whatever your main bag, always bring a small daypack. You'll use it every single day.
Quick packing checklist before you choose
- Check how your luggage will travel: coach, car, boat or on your back.
- Check your airline's size and weight limits.
- Ask yourself whether you can lift your packed bag onto a coach or up a flight of stairs on your own.
- Use packing cubes and pack one outfit fewer than you think you need.
- Leave space for souvenirs.
The honest truth
There will always be a moment on any trip when you wish you'd packed differently. But if you match your bag to how your luggage will travel, keep it light enough to lift yourself, and bring a daypack, you'll get it right far more often than not.
And remember, your luggage is just the vessel. The real adventure is everything you'll experience once you arrive.
Nervous about your first trip? Read the things I wish I knew before my first group trip, or see our Vietnam guide for a full packing list. We always send a trip-specific packing list via Whatsapp before each trip.
Suitcase vs backpack FAQs
Is a suitcase or backpack better for a group tour? For most group tours with coach transfers and hotels, a medium suitcase is easier. For sailing, small boats or jungle lodges, choose a backpack or soft holdall.
Is a wheeled backpack worth it? Yes, if your trip mixes airports and smooth pavements with stairs, sand or boats. It's heavier than a normal backpack, but much more flexible.
What luggage is best for a sailing holiday? A soft holdall or backpack, because cabin storage is small and rigid cases are hard to stow.
Should I bring a daypack as well? Always. You'll use it every day for water, sun cream, a camera and your passport.



